Project Grade 6 Health & Consumer Science

The Petrosyan Water Bill: A Halverpine Home Savings Plan

A four-session grade 6 project in which students audit a fictional household water bill, pick three changes, and build a one-page savings plan for the family.

Objectives

  1. Students will read the price per thousand gallons from a fictional water bill and use it to calculate the monthly total.
  2. Students will write and evaluate an expression for a monthly water bill.
  3. Students will propose three household changes and estimate the gallons and dollars each one saves.

Vocabulary

Key words: service charge, unit price, usage, percent

Teacher overview

A water bill turns a household's habits into a number, and the lines under the amount due show where the water went. Over four sessions students work as home water coaches for the fictional Petrosyan family of Halverpine, pulling the price per thousand gallons off a bill, sizing three changes against national end-use shares, and turning the result into a one-page plan the family could tape inside a cabinet door. The deliverable is that single page, presented at a mock community workshop run by the town's water department. One misconception to address directly is the assumption that the whole bill scales with usage, so that cutting use in half would halve the bill. The fixed monthly service charge does not move, and the plan has to show that it does not.

Rubric

Criterion 1 Emerging 2 Developing 3 Proficient 4 Advanced
Bill mathematics The bill total is missing or the service charge and usage charge are combined incorrectly. The usage charge is right but the fixed service charge is dropped or double counted. The bill is worked correctly, and the expression uses a letter for thousands of gallons with the service charge added separately. The bill and the expression are correct, and the group evaluates the expression for a second usage figure to show the service charge staying put.
Use of the given data Gallon figures appear with no source in the brief. Some figures trace to the brief, others are guessed. Every gallon and dollar figure traces to a number in the brief or to something the family could measure. Figures trace to the brief and the group states plainly which numbers are national averages rather than the Petrosyan family's own measurements.
Meeting the constraints Fewer or more than three changes, or the up-front cost is not addressed. Three changes are named but the cost total is missing or over the limit. Three changes are named, the total up-front cost is at or under sixty dollars, and no change removes drinking or handwashing water. All constraints are met, and the group explains the tradeoff it weighed when dropping a fourth change it wanted to keep.
The one-page plan and talk The page is incomplete or the talk runs long without covering the savings. The page shows the changes but not the savings, or the talk skips the new bill total. The page shows the worked bill, three changes, monthly gallons and dollars saved, and the new total, and the talk covers all of it in two minutes. The page is clear enough for a family to follow without the talk, and the presenter answers the audience question using a number from the page.

Differentiation

Support

Give these groups the June bill already worked out and start them at Milestone 2, so the project centers on choosing and pricing changes rather than on the opening arithmetic. Provide a savings table with the column headings and the price per thousand gallons filled in.

Extension

Ask the group to prepare a second version of the plan for a household of two people rather than four, and to explain in writing which of their three changes saves less in the smaller home and why.

ELL supports

Pre-teach "service charge," "usage," "unit price," and "savings" using a labeled copy of the bill with each part shaded a different color. Provide the sentence frame: "This change saves about ___ gallons a month, which is about ___ dollars a month."

Extensions

Invite a customer service representative from a local utility to review two or three student plans and describe which of the proposed changes their office hears about most often from customers.