Project Grade 8 English Language Arts

Explaining the Fenniscombe Aeration Basin to Ratepayers

A five-session grade 8 project: students write a newsletter feature article explaining how bacteria clean a fictional town's wastewater, with sidebar and glossary.

Objectives

  1. Students will explain a biological treatment process in writing for a non-technical audience.
  2. Students will define technical terms in context rather than in a separate list only.
  3. Students will keep a source log and cite the source behind each technical claim in the article.

Vocabulary

Activated sludge
Activated sludge is a living brown mixture of helpful bacteria and other microbes that wastewater plants grow on purpose. The microbes clean the water by eating the waste in it.
Effluent
Effluent is the cleaned water that leaves a treatment plant at the end of the process. It is tested carefully before being released to a river, lake, or the ocean.
Clarifier
A clarifier is a big round or rectangular tank where water sits calmly so solids can sink to the bottom and be scraped away. Treatment plants use clarifiers at more than one stage of cleaning.

Also: aeration basin, microorganism, sidebar

Teacher overview

Students write a feature article for the quarterly newsletter of a fictional town's water reclamation facility, explaining how the bacteria in an aeration basin do most of the work of cleaning wastewater. The finished piece runs 900 to 1,200 words and arrives with a sidebar, a hand-drawn process figure, and a six-term glossary. The misconception to plan for is that a treatment plant is a set of filters and chemicals, and that living organisms are something to be removed from water rather than the thing doing the cleaning. Expect early drafts to describe the aeration basin as a tank where "chemicals break down waste," and require students to correct that sentence with a cited source before Milestone 3.

Rubric

Criterion Emerging Developing Proficient Advanced
Explanation of the process The article does not explain what happens in the basin, or it gets the order of steps wrong. The steps appear, but the aeration basin's biology is described vaguely, as chemicals or filters doing the work. The order is correct and the role of the bacteria is stated, though one step is thin or out of place. The order of treatment steps is correct and complete, and the reader learns specifically what the bacteria consume and why air is added.
Audience and precision The article reads as notes for a science class rather than as writing for a customer. Terms are listed in the glossary but used undefined in the article, so a customer would stall. Most terms are defined in context and the writing is mostly clear, with one or two unexplained terms. Every technical term is defined in context, sentences are direct, and no jargon passes without help for the reader.
Sources and support No usable log, or claims that appear nowhere in the sources listed. Fewer than four sources, or the log names sources the article never uses. Four sources logged, with one or two claims not tied clearly to a source. Four or more logged sources, each technical claim traceable to one of them, and quotation kept within the one-sentence limit.
Package completeness Two or more parts are missing. One part is missing, or the figure contradicts the article's sequence. All five parts are present, with one part outside its stated length or slightly out of step with the article. Article, sidebar, figure, glossary, and log are all present, within the stated lengths, and the figure matches the order described in the article.

Differentiation

Support

Provide a partly completed source log with two entries already filled in and a paragraph-by-paragraph frame naming the job of each paragraph. Lower the article length to 600 words while holding the requirement that six terms be defined in context, since that requirement carries the standard. Confer with these students at Milestone 3 rather than waiting for the full draft.

Extension

Require a second sidebar written for a different audience, such as a town council member deciding whether to fund new blowers, and an author's note of 150 words explaining which choices changed between the two sidebars and why.

ELL supports

Supply the six glossary terms in advance with an image or diagram beside each, and allow students to draft the process figure and its labels before drafting prose, so the sequence is settled before the sentences are written. Permit the source log to be annotated in a student's first language. Provide the frames "Before the water reaches ___, it first ___" and "The bacteria in the basin use ___ to ___" for the explanatory paragraphs.

Extensions

Have students record a two-minute audio version of the sidebar for the plant's phone information line and compare, in a short paragraph, which sentences had to change when the writing was meant to be heard rather than read.