NGSS · Grades 3–5

3-5-ETS1-1 Define a design problem with criteria and constraints

Define a simple design problem reflecting a need or a want that includes specified criteria for success and constraints on materials, time, or cost.

Why water teaches this standard well

A water filter challenge is the classic way to meet this standard: students define success as clear water and set constraints such as a fixed budget of sand, gravel, and cloth. Framing the problem the way a real utility does, with a target cleanliness and a cost limit, makes the criteria and constraints authentic.

Materials tagged with this code are written to the full standard , and each carries a written note explaining the alignment. See how we review materials.

40 materials aligned to 3-5-ETS1-1

Lesson plans

Grade 3 Lesson plan

Ferngate Flood Barrier: A Grade 3 Model Levee Design

A grade 3 engineering lesson where students build and test a clay-and-stick levee to keep model Ferngate dry when Otter Run floods, then judge the design.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 5 Lesson plan

Alder Grove Rain Garden: A Grade 5 Runoff Sizing Lesson

A grade 5 engineering lesson where students use the roof-runoff formula to size a rain garden for Alder Grove Elementary and decide whether it can hold a storm's water.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Worksheets

Grade 3 Worksheet

Willowmere Water Plant Steps: A Grade 3 Design Worksheet

A grade 3 engineering worksheet where students order the cleaning steps at the fictional Willowmere water plant and compare two plant layouts to pick the better design.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Labs & experiments

Classroom activities

Grade 4 Classroom activity

Marlowbend's Storm Day: A Stormwater Placement Game

A grade 4 team game in which students spend a fixed credit budget placing rain gardens, barrels, and porous pavement on a town grid to keep two low corners dry.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 3 Classroom activity

Marsh Bend School Water-Saving Redesign Stations

A grade 3 engineering station-rotation activity where teams redesign four spots in a fictional school to save water and compare their fixes against a shared goal.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Grade 3 Classroom activity

Garrowmoor's Dry Month: A Grade 3 Reservoir Gauge Game

A 45-minute grade 3 team game where students track a fictional town's reservoir gauge through four dry weeks and play saving cards to finish far above the line.

Science 45 min Answer key

Projects

Grade 5 Project

Halverd Farm Co-op Well Site: A Grade 5 Design Proposal

A three-session grade 5 project where teams rule out two well sites on setback and depth rules, price the survivors, size a tank, and pitch a site.

Engineering & Design 3 sessions, ~135 min total Answer key

Grade 3 Project

Camp Alder Creek Filter Challenge: A Grade 3 Design Project

A four-session grade 3 engineering project where teams design and fair-test a sand and gravel filter for a fictional camp's muddy creek water on a fixed budget.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~180 min total Answer key

Quizzes & test questions

Grade 3 Quiz & test questions

Pinfold Farm Well Cover Choices: A Grade 3 Design Quiz

A grade 3 engineering quiz on three well cover designs for a fictional farm town, sorting design goals from limits and judging which cover to build.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 4 Quiz & test questions

Ellaby Island Camp's Dry Month: Comparing Three Water Plans

A grade 4 design-review quiz in which students judge three water-supply plans for a fictional island camp against a supply target, a no-rain rule, and a token limit.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 5 Quiz & test questions

Merrowgate Hydrant Map: A Grade 5 Design Review Quiz

A grade 5 quiz where students review a fictional town's hydrant plan on a coordinate grid, test it against a coverage rule, and judge a proposed move.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Graphic organizers

Grade 3 Graphic organizer

Limbrook Creek Mud Problem: A Grade 3 Design Frame

A grade 3 organizer that walks students from a muddy runoff chain behind a fictional school to written design goals, limits, and a choice between two fixes.

Engineering & Design 35 min Answer key

Grade 4 Graphic organizer

A Reed Bed for Quillton Park Pond: A Design Decision Chain

A grade 4 six-box decision chain organizer tracing a fictional park board's choice of a planted reed bed over a settling box or a chemical feeder, with an exemplar.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key