NGSS · Middle School (6–8)

MS-ETS1-3 Combine the best features of designs into a new solution

Analyze data from tests to determine similarities and differences among several design solutions to identify the best characteristics of each that can be combined into a new solution to better meet the criteria for success.

Why water teaches this standard well

After testing several filter recipes, students merge the best layers of each, perhaps one design's gravel base with another's charcoal stage, into an improved prototype. Combining winning features from multiple tests is exactly how treatment trains are optimized in practice.

Materials tagged with this code are written to the full standard , and each carries a written note explaining the alignment. See how we review materials.

17 materials aligned to MS-ETS1-3

Labs & experiments

Grade 6 Lab / experiment

Testing Three Pipe Bedding Materials for Oskett Lane

Students load a model pipe on soil, sand, and pea gravel, then measure settling, drainage, and soil movement to pick the bedding a fictional water main job needs.

Engineering & Design 60 min Answer key

Grade 7 Lab / experiment

Braycott Basin Baffles: Testing Three Layouts for Clearer Water

A grade 7 lab where teams test three baffle layouts in a model settling basin, then build a fourth that combines features from their best layout and a partner team's.

Engineering & Design 2 sessions, ~90 min total Answer key

Grade 8 Lab / experiment

Crayfen Ridge Pond Covers: Testing Three Evaporation Shields

A grade 8 lab in which teams run four-day evaporation trials on three cover designs, score each against stated criteria, and build a combined cover from the winners.

Engineering & Design 2 sessions, ~105 min total Answer key

Grade 6 Lab / experiment

Pellham Flats Well Screen Gravel Pack Design Lab

Students build three model well screens with different gravel pack depths, time how fast each drains, and measure how much sand each lets through before choosing one.

Engineering & Design 60 min Answer key

Classroom activities

Grade 6 Classroom activity

Camp Marloch Constructed Wetland Design Activity

A grade 6 engineering station rotation where teams score competing constructed-wetland design options on a rubric, then combine the best features into one class design.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Projects

Grade 7 Project

Ravensgill Creek Shade Structures: Cooling a Trout Reach

A five-session grade 7 build-and-test project where teams design bank shade structures on a model reach, run three timed heat trials, and combine the best features.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~300 min total Answer key

Grade 8 Project

Tarnholt Lagoon Aeration: Model, Test, and Refine a Retrofit

A five-session grade 8 project where teams build tabletop lagoon models, test three air-delivery layouts for dead zones, and recommend a retrofit to a village board.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~250 min total Answer key

Quizzes & test questions

Graphic organizers

Grade 7 Graphic organizer

Fernlow Lagoon Polishing Filter: Combining Test Results

A grade 7 organizer for reading three media-bed test results, naming the feature worth keeping from each, and stacking those features into one combined filter design.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key