NGSS · Middle School (6–8)

MS-ETS1-2 Evaluate competing design solutions against criteria

Evaluate competing design solutions using a systematic process to determine how well they meet the criteria and constraints of the problem.

Why water teaches this standard well

Scoring several water filter or rain-garden designs on a shared rubric of clarity, flow rate, and cost is the systematic evaluation this standard wants. It is the same decision matrix a utility uses to choose among treatment options, and it pairs directly with MS-ESS3-3 on a filtration challenge.

Materials tagged with this code are written to the full standard , and each carries a written note explaining the alignment. See how we review materials.

69 materials aligned to MS-ETS1-2

Lesson plans

Grade 8 Lesson plan

Morley Cross Hard Water: Choosing How to Soften a Supply

A 50-minute grade 8 lesson where students weigh central lime softening, ion exchange, and household rebates against hardness, chloride, cost, and fairness criteria.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 8 Lesson plan

Roxby Weir's New Source: A Four-Role Design Review Panel

A 55-minute grade 8 lesson where students take four water-sector roles, judge three new-source options from their own criterion, and negotiate one recommendation.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Aridell Fog Catcher Water Harvest Design Lesson

A grade 6 engineering lesson where students size and compare fog-catcher mesh designs for a dry village, using area and unit rates to predict daily water harvest.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Cutter Hollow Erosion Barrier Design and Sediment Test

Teams model a hillside in a tray, measure sediment reaching a downstream cup, then design and test a barrier that reduces erosion for the fictional town of Cutter Hollow.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Millbrook Creek Household Filter Design Challenge

Teams define a clarity target and a 20-credit budget, then design, build, and test a three-layer household water filter for the fictional town of Millbrook Creek.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Worksheets

Grade 6 Worksheet

Choosing a Water Meter Size for the Pinkney Bakery

Students match a fictional bakery's lowest and highest water demands against three meter ranges and charges, then pick a meter and revisit it for a drip line.

Engineering & Design 35 min Answer key

Grade 8 Worksheet

Marlin Quay Storm Inlet Screens: Choosing a Bar Spacing

A grade 8 worksheet using five tested inlet screen designs: students model flow as a linear function of bar spacing, then pick the one design meeting all three criteria.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Grade 6 Worksheet

Amboti Village Handpump Well Drawdown Worksheet

A grade 6 engineering worksheet where students design a village handpump well, finding drawdown from water levels and pump output from unit rates and a rate table.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 6 Worksheet

Otterkill Creek Trash Boom Capture Design Worksheet

A grade 6 engineering worksheet where students design a floating trash boom for a creek, using percent capture, a unit rate, and a ratio table to meet a litter goal.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Math problem sets

Grade 6 Math problem set

Hollisgate Farm Drip Line Emitter Spacing Problems

Ten problems where students divide a row length by two emitter spacings on a fictional pepper farm, then test each drip design against a permit and a crop rule.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Grade 6 Math problem set

Sedgewater Hatchery Aerator Selection Problems

Ten problems where students size an aerator set for a fictional trout hatchery raceway, then compare two models on purchase price, energy use, and years to pay back.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 6 Math problem set

Cape Vorne Desalination: Energy and Recovery Problems

A grade 6 math set comparing a fictional desalination plant's energy use with ordinary treatment, and finding the seawater and brine behind each batch of fresh water.

Science 40 min Answer key

Grade 6 Math problem set

Pinebrook Garden Club Irrigation Pump Selection Problems

Eight problems where a fictional garden club compares two irrigation pumps' unit rates, solving one-step equations to find pumping time and check a time rule.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Labs & experiments

Grade 6 Lab / experiment

Choosing a Weir Notch Shape for Wilmot Brook

Students build three weir plates, read the water height at a slow and a fast flow, and pick the notch shape that meets a fictional gauge's three rules.

Engineering & Design 2 sessions, ~90 min total Answer key

Grade 6 Lab / experiment

Testing Three Pipe Bedding Materials for Oskett Lane

Students load a model pipe on soil, sand, and pea gravel, then measure settling, drainage, and soil movement to pick the bedding a fictional water main job needs.

Engineering & Design 60 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lab / experiment

Hartsel Reservoir Evaporation Cover Design Lab

A grade 6 engineering lab where students build and test covers to slow evaporation from model reservoirs, then compare water loss to pick the best design.

Engineering & Design 2 sessions, ~60 min total Answer key

Classroom activities

Grade 6 Classroom activity

Camp Marloch Constructed Wetland Design Activity

A grade 6 engineering station rotation where teams score competing constructed-wetland design options on a rubric, then combine the best features into one class design.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 8 Classroom activity

Control-Room Icons: Designing Plant-Operator Symbols

A grade 8 art activity where teams design a set of control-room icons for a water plant, then evaluate competing icon sets against shared design criteria in a critique.

Art & Music 55 min Answer key

Grade 7 Classroom activity

Chalkmere Utility Design Review: Four Constraint Stations

A grade 7 station rotation where teams make one decision at each of four water-utility desks, then compare the constraints that pushed each role toward a choice.

Engineering & Design 60 min Answer key

Grade 6 Classroom activity

Cobble Hill Trade-off Draft: A Water Main Upgrade Game

A card-drafting game where teams build a 3-card water main upgrade package within a point budget and test it against a town council's three design criteria.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Debate kits

Projects

Grade 6 Project

A Phased Water Plan for the Gossett Ridge Homes

Teams take three water-sector roles and design a two-phase plan for a fictional hillside neighborhood, since the grant pays for only part of the work they want to build.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~240 min total Answer key

Grade 7 Project

Millbrandt Drainage District: A Nutrient Interception Design

A five-session grade 7 project where teams screen four nitrate-cutting designs against land, budget, and drainage limits, then pitch one to a fictional drainage board.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~300 min total Answer key

Grade 7 Project

Varnholt Flats Brackish Wells: Designing an RO Pretreatment

A four-session grade 7 project where teams order and justify the treatment steps ahead of a fictional brackish-well membrane plant, then defend the train to the board.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~240 min total Answer key

Grade 8 Project

Stonebeck Creek Monitoring: Designing a Sampling Network

A three-session grade 8 project in which teams design, pilot, and defend a creek sampling network that can detect whether a street-sweeping program is working.

Engineering & Design 3 sessions, ~150 min total Answer key

Grade 6 Project

Greywater Biofilter Design for the Fernwood Community Garden

A grade 6 engineering project where teams design a small layered biofilter to clean handwashing greywater for garden irrigation, within a fixed budget and footprint.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~170 min total Answer key

Quizzes & test questions

Grade 6 Quiz & test questions

Design Review of the Hearnside Dam Spillway Plan

A 20-point grade 6 review in which students check a fictional spillway plan against a flood rule and a freeboard rule, then evaluate a wider replacement design.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 6 Quiz & test questions

Marne Water Plant Settling Basin Design Assessment

A grade 6 engineering assessment where students size a rectangular settling basin, find detention time and removal percent, and pick a design change to meet a goal.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Graphic organizers

Grade 6 Graphic organizer

Choosing a Disinfection Method for the Tinbury Wells

A grade 6 scoring matrix that rates chlorine tablets, a liquid feed pump, and an ultraviolet reactor against four rules for a fictional small water system.

Engineering & Design 25 min Answer key

Grade 7 Graphic organizer

Fernlow Lagoon Polishing Filter: Combining Test Results

A grade 7 organizer for reading three media-bed test results, naming the feature worth keeping from each, and stacking those features into one combined filter design.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 7 Graphic organizer

Pentarrow PFAS Options: A Treatment Decision Matrix

A grade 7 organizer pairing a pass-or-fail constraint screen with a weighted scoring matrix for three PFAS treatment options at a fictional water district.

Engineering & Design 25 min Answer key