NGSS · Middle School (6–8)

MS-ETS1-1 Define criteria and constraints of a design problem

Define the criteria and constraints of a design problem with sufficient precision to ensure a successful solution, taking into account relevant scientific principles and potential impacts on people and the natural environment that may limit possible solutions.

Why water teaches this standard well

A water treatment or stormwater challenge forces students to state criteria and constraints with real precision: a target turbidity, a fixed budget, and impacts on the downstream community. Defining a water problem this carefully is exactly the work engineers do before designing any piece of infrastructure.

Materials tagged with this code are written to the full standard , and each carries a written note explaining the alignment. See how we review materials.

64 materials aligned to MS-ETS1-1

Lesson plans

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Where to Build Post-and-Brush Dams on Sedge Run

Students weigh three stream reaches against a post supply and a one-day work limit, then choose where a fictional crew should build low post-and-brush dams.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 8 Lesson plan

Morley Cross Hard Water: Choosing How to Soften a Supply

A 50-minute grade 8 lesson where students weigh central lime softening, ion exchange, and household rebates against hardness, chloride, cost, and fairness criteria.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 8 Lesson plan

Roxby Weir's New Source: A Four-Role Design Review Panel

A 55-minute grade 8 lesson where students take four water-sector roles, judge three new-source options from their own criterion, and negotiate one recommendation.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Bramfell School Backflow Preventer Design Lesson

A 50-minute lesson where students pick a backflow assembly for a fictional school greenhouse, then check the device still leaves enough pressure at the sprinklers.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Wrenfield Lead Service Line Replacement Plan Lesson

A grade 6 engineering lesson where students design a phased plan to replace a town's lead service lines on a deadline and budget, then check it with rate and percent.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 7 Lesson plan

Threshel Brook Culvert: Criteria for a Farm Road Crossing

A grade 7 lesson where students use a map scale to find a drainage area, size the design flow for a fictional culvert, and separate its criteria from its constraints.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Millbrook Creek Household Filter Design Challenge

Teams define a clarity target and a 20-credit budget, then design, build, and test a three-layer household water filter for the fictional town of Millbrook Creek.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 6 Lesson plan

Sable Ridge Water Tower Height and Stability Challenge

Teams design, build, and test a straw-and-tape model water tower across two rounds, meeting a height and load requirement for the fictional town of Sable Ridge.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Worksheets

Grade 6 Worksheet

Wembrey Ombry Street Leak Sensor Spacing Worksheet

Eleven items where students space leak sensors along an old water main in a fictional town, price the sensor set, and compare what the leaks cost with finding them.

Engineering & Design 35 min Answer key

Grade 7 Worksheet

Pike Hollow PFAS Filter: Sizing Carbon and Flow

Students design a fictional town's carbon filter for PFAS, using percent removal to check each well against the 4.0 ppt limit and sizing the daily flow.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Grade 6 Worksheet

Corrigan Bend Water-Quality Sampling Plan Worksheet

Nine items where students size a river water-quality sampling plan against a coverage rule and a fixed budget, then compare a bulk-price alternative.

Engineering & Design 35 min Answer key

Math problem sets

Grade 6 Math problem set

Harrowfield Well 3 Carbon Filter Sizing and Cost Problems

Ten problems in which students size carbon treatment vessels for a fictional town's PFAS-affected well, then work out media cost, yearly cost, and percent of budget.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Grade 6 Math problem set

Oakspur Plant Detention Time: How Long Water Settles

A grade 6 science math set where students find a fictional basin's volume, then divide by flow to get detention time and check it against the 2-to-4-hour design range.

Science 40 min Answer key

Grade 8 Math problem set

Nettlebrook Reservoir Spillway: A Grade 8 Scatter Plot Set

A grade 8 problem set where students scatter-plot eight years of rainfall and reservoir inflow data, fit a trend line by eye, and set a spillway capacity constraint.

Engineering & Design 40 min Answer key

Classroom activities

Grade 6 Classroom activity

Corrantry Hill Pressure Zone Placement Activity

Groups act as a utility design team, finding water pressure at six houses on a fictional hillside and deciding which ones belong in a booster-served upper zone.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 6 Classroom activity

Cobble Hill Trade-off Draft: A Water Main Upgrade Game

A card-drafting game where teams build a 3-card water main upgrade package within a point budget and test it against a town council's three design criteria.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Projects

Grades 6–7 Project

Schoolyard Stormwater Runoff: An Audit and Design Project

Teams map their schoolyard's hard and soft surfaces, calculate real stormwater runoff in gallons, trace where it drains, and pitch a fix to a real school decision-maker.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~250 min total Answer key

Grade 6 Project

A Phased Water Plan for the Gossett Ridge Homes

Teams take three water-sector roles and design a two-phase plan for a fictional hillside neighborhood, since the grant pays for only part of the work they want to build.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~240 min total Answer key

Grade 7 Project

Millbrandt Drainage District: A Nutrient Interception Design

A five-session grade 7 project where teams screen four nitrate-cutting designs against land, budget, and drainage limits, then pitch one to a fictional drainage board.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~300 min total Answer key

Grade 7 Project

Varnholt Flats Brackish Wells: Designing an RO Pretreatment

A four-session grade 7 project where teams order and justify the treatment steps ahead of a fictional brackish-well membrane plant, then defend the train to the board.

Engineering & Design 4 sessions, ~240 min total Answer key

Grade 8 Project

Beneath the Streets: An Aging-Water-Mains Exhibit Design

A grade 8 art project where teams design a scaled three-panel museum exhibit about why old water mains break, within a fixed panel size and a fictional budget.

Art & Music 4 sessions, ~200 min total Answer key

Quizzes & test questions

Grade 6 Quiz & test questions

Ferrow Bend Ice Rink Meltwater Reuse Assessment

A 25-point quiz on a fictional rink's plan to capture and reuse ice-resurfacer meltwater, with multiple-choice and computation items on volume, savings, and fill time.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 8 Quiz & test questions

Oldcastle Mill Race Micro-Hydro: A Design Screening Quiz

A 20-point grade 8 quiz on screening a micro-hydro project, mixing constraint identification with forebay volume, pressure, and flow conversion computations.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Graphic organizers

Grade 6 Graphic organizer

Choosing a Disinfection Method for the Tinbury Wells

A grade 6 scoring matrix that rates chlorine tablets, a liquid feed pump, and an ultraviolet reactor against four rules for a fictional small water system.

Engineering & Design 25 min Answer key

Grade 7 Graphic organizer

Pentarrow PFAS Options: A Treatment Decision Matrix

A grade 7 organizer pairing a pass-or-fail constraint screen with a weighted scoring matrix for three PFAS treatment options at a fictional water district.

Engineering & Design 25 min Answer key

Grade 7 Graphic organizer

Quillmoss Kiln Street Main: Criteria and Constraints Frame

A grade 7 organizer that turns vague meeting comments about a failing water main into measurable requirements, sorted into criteria and constraints with named impacts.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 8 Graphic organizer

Calderstone Fields Runoff: A Criteria and Constraints Frame

A grade 8 definition organizer that separates measurable criteria from hard constraints before students propose any fix for nutrient runoff from school athletic fields.

Engineering & Design 25 min Answer key