NGSS · High School (9–12)

HS-ETS1-3 Evaluate a solution against prioritized criteria and trade-offs

Evaluate a solution to a complex real-world problem based on prioritized criteria and trade-offs that account for a range of constraints, including cost, safety, reliability, and aesthetics as well as possible social, cultural, and environmental impacts.

Why water teaches this standard well

Water projects force real trade-offs among cost, safety, reliability, and community impact, which is precisely what this standard asks students to weigh. Evaluating whether a city should build a new reservoir, expand reuse, or invest in conservation puts every one of those constraints on the table at once.

Materials tagged with this code are written to the full standard , and each carries a written note explaining the alignment. See how we review materials.

95 materials aligned to HS-ETS1-3

Lesson plans

Grade 12 Lesson plan

Water Age in the Quintrell Ridge Tank: A Turnover Lesson

A grade 12 lesson where students compute water age in a fictional storage tank from volume and daily throughput, then weigh storage size against disinfectant residual.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Grade 10 Lesson plan

Langmere Reservoir Turnover: Choosing an Intake Depth

A grade 10 lesson using an August depth profile of temperature, oxygen, and manganese to decide which intake a reservoir plant should draw from before fall turnover.

Science 50 min Answer key

Grade 9 Lesson plan

Ranking Water Main Replacements with a Decision Matrix

A 50-minute grade 9 engineering lesson where students build a weighted decision matrix to rank three aging water mains for replacement under a limited budget.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Worksheets

Grade 10 Worksheet

Pennyford Sanitary Sewer: Inflow and Infiltration Math

A grade 10 worksheet measuring storm water leaking into a fictional town's sanitary sewer, then pricing the extra treatment and testing what a lining project would fix.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 9 Worksheet

Corvale's PFAS Pilot: GAC Removal Efficiency Worksheet

A grade 9 science worksheet on a fictional town's activated-carbon pilot, where students calculate PFAS removal efficiency and compare treated water to the federal limit.

Science 40 min Answer key

Math problem sets

Grade 9 Math problem set

Elmcrest Storage Tank: Fire Flow, Reserve, and Volume

A grade 9 problem set where students model a fictional town's cylindrical tank, find its volume in gallons, and track how much water a two-hour fire flow draws down.

Science 45 min Answer key

Grade 9 Math problem set

Ash Creek Treatment Plant: Detention, Filters, Chlorine

A grade 9 engineering set on a surface water plant: students size a sedimentation basin's detention time, a filter loading rate, and a chlorine feed in pounds per day.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 9 Math problem set

Marsh Landing Seawater Reverse Osmosis: Recovery and Flux

A grade 9 engineering set on a seawater reverse osmosis plant: students find permeate and concentrate flows, membrane flux, a concentration factor, and daily energy.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Labs & experiments

Grade 11 Lab / experiment

Aldwyn Reservoir Jar Test: Finding the Optimal Alum Dose

A grade 11 lab where students run a five-jar coagulation test on cloudy water, plot clarity against alum dose, and scale the best dose to a plant feed rate.

Engineering & Design 2 sessions, ~90 min total Answer key

Grade 10 Lab / experiment

Upwood Creek Chlorine Demand: A Dose and Residual Lab

Grade 10 students dose four water samples that carry increasing amounts of leaf matter, measure the free chlorine left after 15 minutes, and calculate chlorine demand.

Science 55 min Answer key

Grade 9 Lab / experiment

Building and Testing a Multimedia Water Filter Column

A grade 9 engineering lab where students build a gravel, sand, and charcoal filter column, then test it by measuring water clarity and flow rate across two trials.

Engineering & Design 55 min Answer key

Classroom activities

Grade 10 Classroom activity

Ferrowdale Main Break: An Operations Tabletop

A 55-minute grade 10 tabletop exercise where student crews isolate a broken water main in timed rounds and calculate lost water, tank drawdown, and zone pressure.

Science 55 min Answer key

Grade 10 Classroom activity

Westhorne's Cross-Connection Hazard Hunt Stations

A 50-minute grade 10 station rotation where teams inspect six cross-connection sites, choose backflow assemblies, and calculate the pressures that drive backflow.

Science 50 min Answer key

Grade 10 Classroom activity

Vellamore Reverse Osmosis Troubleshooting Rounds

A grade 10 station rotation where teams read operating data from four fictional membrane trains, calculate flow and salt passage changes, and diagnose each fault.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Grade 11 Classroom activity

Brellin Vale Control Room: An Alarm Triage Simulation

A grade 11 role-play in which shift teams triage eight simultaneous plant and distribution alarms, rank them by consequence, and state the first operator action.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 11 Classroom activity

Halverstock Campus Cross-Connection Survey Rotation

A grade 11 station rotation where student inspectors survey six campus cross connections and select the minimum adequate backflow prevention assembly for each one.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Reading passages

Writing prompts

Debate kits

Grade 10 Debate kit

Should Cardington Switch to Chloramine Disinfection?

A grade 10 science debate kit on converting a city's distribution system from free chlorine to chloramine, with two-sided evidence on byproducts, residual, and risk.

Science 2 sessions, ~90 min total Answer key

Grade 9 Debate kit

Where Ivenden's Concentrate Goes: River or Injection Well

A grade 9 science debate kit on whether a fictional brackish water plant should send its salty reverse osmosis concentrate to a river or into a deep injection well.

Science 2 sessions, ~90 min total Answer key

Projects

Grade 11 Project

Cindermoss Creek Mine Drainage: A Passive Treatment Design

A six-session grade 11 project: teams design a gravity-driven treatment train for an abandoned mine discharge, sized by iron loading and limited by land and budget.

Engineering & Design 6 sessions, ~360 min total Answer key

Grade 11 Project

Thistlecomb Road Culvert: A Fish Passage and Flood Design

A six-session grade 11 project in which teams size a stream crossing that passes the design storm, restores trout passage, and fits a fixed budget and closure window.

Engineering & Design 6 sessions, ~360 min total Answer key

Grade 12 Project

Marrowgate Main Replacement: A Capital Plan Project

A grade 12 project where teams rank six aging water mains in a fictional town with a weighted scoring matrix, select a portfolio within budget, and pitch a capital plan.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~250 min total Answer key

Grade 12 Project

Aquifer Storage and Recovery for the Lattimore Basin

A grade 12 science capstone in which students test whether winter surplus water can be stored underground, then defend a recommendation to a fictional agency board.

Science 6 sessions, ~330 min total Answer key

Grade 9 Project

Juniper Bend Treatment Train Design Challenge

A grade 9 engineering project where teams design a four-stage drinking water treatment train for a fictional town within a flow, footprint, and budget.

Engineering & Design 5 sessions, ~275 min total Answer key

Quizzes & test questions

Grade 11 Quiz & test questions

Harkin Row Campus Stormwater Retrofit: Design Assessment

A grade 11 engineering assessment on a campus stormwater retrofit, covering impervious area, runoff volume, bioretention storage, drawdown time, and cost per gallon.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 9 Quiz & test questions

Quennfield Plant Upgrade: A Design and Sizing Unit Test

A 35-point grade 9 unit test on a fictional plant upgrade, mixing criteria and constraint items with detention time, chemical feed, filter loading, and pressure math.

Engineering & Design 50 min Answer key

Graphic organizers

Grade 10 Graphic organizer

Quarryfen Wellfield Protection Zones: A Land-Use Organizer

A grade 10 organizer mapping four wellhead protection zones around a fictional public well, matching the threats in each zone to controls and to who enforces them.

Engineering & Design 45 min Answer key

Grade 11 Graphic organizer

Kelbrook Reclaimed Water: A Reuse Tier Organizer

A grade 11 tier organizer matching five reclaimed water end uses to the treatment barriers, quality targets, and monitoring each one demands, with a completed exemplar.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key

Grade 12 Graphic organizer

Fettleworth Orchard Irrigation: A Weighted Decision Matrix

A grade 12 organizer where students set criteria, assign weights, and score solid-set sprinklers against subsurface drip for a fictional orchard facing a pumping limit.

Engineering & Design 30 min Answer key